Abstract

In a previous report records were studied of 256 in-patients who were discharged as undiagnosed, i.e. in-patients who at the time of discharge did not have a definable psychiatric illness (Welner, Liss, Robins and Richardson, 1972). In that study it was shown that when rigorous criteria for psychiatric research (Feighner, Robins, Guze, Woodruff, Winokur and Munoz, 1972) were used 68 per cent of these patients met the criteria for an established psychiatric disorder. It was concluded that: (1) The chart review diagnoses for a population of undiagnosed patients consisted of a variety of established psychiatric disorders and the population was not homogeneous. (The chart review diagnosis is a diagnosis obtained by review of the patients' hospital records and evaluating the information by using diagnostic criteria for psychiatric disorders.) (2) The most efficient way to arrive at a diagnosis was by structured rather than conventional narrative interview. This study is a follow-up study of these patients and attempts to evaluate the validity of the chart review diagnosis. A concordance between the chart review diagnosis and follow-up diagnosis supports the above conclusions. The follow-up study also served to establish diagnosis in patients who had too few symptoms initially to meet the criteria for a diagnosis.

Keywords

ConcordanceMedical diagnosisMedicineChartPsychiatryPsychiatric diagnosisPopulationMedical recordNarrative reviewPediatricsIntensive care medicineSurgeryPathology

Affiliated Institutions

Related Publications

Primary Affective Disorder

A group of patients whose conditions were diagnosed as primary affective disorder was followed up prospectively after a five-year interval. The patients were reinterviewed blind...

1974 Archives of General Psychiatry 16 citations

Publication Info

Year
1972
Type
article
Volume
121
Issue
565
Pages
647-651
Citations
23
Access
Closed

External Links

Social Impact

Altmetric

Social media, news, blog, policy document mentions

Citation Metrics

23
OpenAlex

Cite This

Jay L. Liss, Amos Welner, Eli Robins (1972). Undiagnosed Psychiatric Patients. The British Journal of Psychiatry , 121 (565) , 647-651. https://doi.org/10.1192/bjp.121.6.647

Identifiers

DOI
10.1192/bjp.121.6.647