Understanding the Impact of Value Selection Heuristics in Scheduling Problems

2025 arXiv (Cornell University) 2,380 citations

Abstract

It has been observed that value selection heuristics have less impact than other heuristic choices when solving hard combinatorial optimization (CO) problems. It is often thought that this is because more time is spent on unsatisfiable sub-problems where the value ordering is irrelevant. In this paper we investigate this belief in the scheduling domain and come up with a more detailed explanation. We find that, even though there are less relevant choices to be made on hard instances, each mistake tends to have a bigger impact, to a point where the potential gain from a value heuristic predominates. Moreover, we observe two interesting and relatively surprising phenomena when solving scheduling problems. First, the accuracy of a given value selection heuristic decreases with the optimality gap. Second, the computational penalty of a mistake increases with the accuracy of the heuristic. For the first observation, we argue that on hard problems, constraint propagation removes a large portion of choices that align with the intuition behind the heuristic. This means that the heuristic faces mostly difficult choices. For the second observation, we argue that simple heuristics tend to make more mistakes on intuitive choice points, and the computational cost for refuting these mistakes is smaller than for those made by a more accurate heuristic.

Keywords

Inductive biasStatistical relational learningComputer scienceGraphArtificial intelligenceTheoretical computer scienceMulti-task learningRelational databaseData miningEconomics

Related Publications

Publication Info

Year
2025
Type
preprint
Citations
2380
Access
Closed

External Links

Social Impact

Social media, news, blog, policy document mentions

Citation Metrics

2380
OpenAlex

Cite This

Peter Battaglia, Jessica B. Hamrick, Victor Bapst et al. (2025). Understanding the Impact of Value Selection Heuristics in Scheduling Problems. arXiv (Cornell University) . https://doi.org/10.4230/lipics.cp.2025.27

Identifiers

DOI
10.4230/lipics.cp.2025.27